Distinct Cognitive Linguistic Profiles in Struggling Elementary School Learners
Abstract Low academic achievement in reading and writing reflects substantial variability in underlying cognitive–linguistic mechanisms that is not always fully captured in empirical research. This study examined learning profiles among children with persistent low academic achievement using a multidimensional framework integrating linguistic and neurocognitive domains. A teacher-referred sample of students in the 3rd to 5th grades was classified a priori into three groups based on semantic definition and phonological awareness and compared on standardized measures of reading, writing, arithmetic, memory, attention, and executive functions. Three distinct learning profiles were identified: one characterized by preserved semantic and phonological skills despite persistent academic difficulties; a second marked by phonological awareness weaknesses accompanied by working memory limitations; and a third showing combined semantic and phonological impairments associated with broader neurocognitive vulnerabilities, particularly in working and semantic memory. These findings demonstrate that similar academic outcomes may arise from functionally distinct cognitive–linguistic pathways and support profile-based, mechanism-oriented approaches to the study, assessment, and support of children with low academic achievement in reading and writing.
Lagus S, Befi-Lopes DM