Peer-reviewed article
1176. Experience with PCV10 Implementation in Colombia and More Severe Course of Pneumococcal Pneumonia in children: A Multicenter Study, 2008 – 2019 (Neumocolombia Network)
Tobar I, Londoño J, Drews C, Beltran S, Castro A et al. ·
Summary
Written by AI, not yet AICS's view · claude-haiku-4-5-20251001This study tracked pneumococcal pneumonia cases in Colombian children before and after the introduction of PCV10 vaccine in 2012. While the vaccine successfully reduced cases caused by the targeted serotypes, it was followed by an increase in cases from non-vaccine serotypes, particularly serotype 19A, which caused more severe disease. Children infected with these new predominant serotypes required more intensive care, longer hospitalization, and stronger antibiotics than those infected with vaccine-covered serotypes.
Key points
- PCV10 vaccination significantly reduced the targeted serotypes (serotype 1 dropped from 11.2% to 3.1%; serotype 14 from 24.6% to 7.8%)
- Non-vaccine serotypes increased after PCV10 introduction, with serotype 19A rising from 3% to 30.2% of cases
- Complicated pneumonia increased from 13.4% to 31.8% after PCV10 introduction
- PICU admission rates increased from 32.8% to 51.6%, and hospitalization length increased from 8 to 12 days
- Serotypes 19A, 3, and 6A showed higher severity with greater PICU requirements (56.9%, 59.4%, and 42.8% respectively) compared to vaccine serotypes
Limitations
The study is observational, comparing two time periods rather than using randomized controls, so causality cannot be definitively established. The disclosures reveal substantial financial relationships between authors and vaccine manufacturers, which may influence interpretation of findings.
Abstract
Abstract Background Pneumococcal conjugate vaccines (PCV) have decreased pneumonia in children. Colombia introduced massive vaccination with PCV10 in 2012. Methods Pneumococcal pneumonia cases from 10 hospitals part of an active surveillance network for invasive pneumococcal disease were included. Two periods were compared, pre-PCV10: 2008-2012 and post-PCV10: 2014-2019. The objective was to compare characteristics and outcomes before and after PCV10. Results 370 cases were included. Serotype 1(15, 11.2%) and 14 (33, 24.6%) were the most frequent in Pre-PCV10, with only 4(3%) 19A and 1(0.7%) serotype 3. Post-PCV10, serotype 1 decreased to 6(3.1%), 14 to 15(7.8%), while 19A increased to 58(30.2%), serotype 3 to 32(16.7%) and 6A to 7(3.6%) (p = < 0.001), (Graph 1). Complicated pneumonia (CN) also increased (13.4% to 31,8%) (p< 0,001). Pre-PVC10, 44% of CN were due to PCV10 serotypes; with no PCV13 serotypes cases. Post-vaccine period, PCV10 explained only 8.2% and PCV13 60.6%(p < 0.001) of CN. Comparing PICU requirement among predominant serotypes on each period; 23.5% of serotypes 14 and 27.2% of serotypes 1 were admitted, while 59.4% of serotypes 3, 56.9 % of 19A and 42.8% of 6A required PICU. The median of hospitalization increased from 8(5.5-15) to 12 (7-22) days (p < 0.001), as well as the frequency of PICU, 32.8% to 51.6 %, (p = 0.001). Penicillin prescription was similar (17.2% -15.7%), with decrease in ampicillin use (28.4% - 3.6%) and increase ampicillin-sulbactam (0.7% to 24%), and ceftriaxone / clindamycin (0.7% to 5.7%) in post-PCV10. The duration of empirical antibiotic treatment was 7(4-11) and increased to 10(6-17) (p = < 0.001). Lethality showed a slight, non-significant increase between periods 7.5% vs. 9.9% (p = 0.57). (Table1) Graph 1. Serotype distribution 2008 - 2019 Year 2012, PCV10 introduced 2 + 1 schedule. Table 1. Outcomes in the Pre-PCV10 and Post-PCV10 Period Conclusion PCV10 significantly decreased vaccine serotypes, with increase in PCV13 serotypes. 19A, 3 and 6A the predominant serotypes had greater severity including PICU admission, CN and more resistance, with an increase in the use of broad-spectrum antibiotics and longer hospitalization. The current data support national and regional evidence on the importance of replacing PCV10 to a higher valence that include 19A, as PCV13, with the aim of reducing the circulation, particularly of this serotype. Disclosures Ivan Felipe Gutiérrez Tobar, n/a, Pfizer and MSD (Advisor or Review Panel member, Research Grant or Support, Speaker’s Bureau, Has received support from Pfizer and MSD for participation in congresses and has received conference payments from Pfizer)Pfizer and MSD (Speaker’s Bureau, Other Financial or Material Support, Has received support from Pfizer for participation in congresses) Cristina Mariño Drews, n/a, Pfizer (Other Financial or Material Support, Has received support from Pfizer for participation in congresses) Sandra Beltran, n/a, Pfizer (Other Financial or Material Support, Has received support from Pfizer for participation in congresses) Aura Lucia Leal Castro, MD, Pfizer and MSD (Research Grant or Support, Speaker’s Bureau, Other Financial or Material Support, Has received support from Pfizer for participation in congresses) Aura Lucia Leal Castro, n/a, Pfizer and MSD (Research Grant or Support, Speaker’s Bureau, Other Financial or Material Support, Has received support from Pfizer for participation in congresses) Jaime alberto Patiño-Niño, n/a, Pfizer (Research Grant or Support, Speaker’s Bureau, Other Financial or Material Support, Has received support from Pfizer for participation in congresses) Martha Isabel Alvarez-Olmos, n/a, Pfizer (Other Financial or Material Support, Has received support from Pfizer for participation in congresses) Rocio Barrero Barreto, n/a, Pfizer and MSD (Other Financial or Material Support, Has received support from Pfizer and MSD for participation in congresses and has received conference payments from Pfizer) Fabio Espinosa, n/a, MSD (Research Grant or Support, Other Financial or Material Support, Has received support from MSD for other research.) Nicolas Ramos, n/a, Pfizer (Other Financial or Material Support, Has received support from Pfizer for participation in congresses) Vivian Marcela Moreno Mejia, n/a, Pfizer (Research Grant or Support)
Findings the Hub has extracted
Each claim below is labelled by its type of design and links back to this report.
Problem
Pneumococcal pneumonia in children causing severe disease, hospitalization, and complications
- Intervention
- PCV10 pneumococcal conjugate vaccine introduced in Colombia in 2012 using a 2+1 schedule
- Population
- Children with invasive pneumococcal disease in 10 Colombian hospitals
Key finding
Vaccine serotypes (1 and 14) decreased significantly (p<0.001) but were replaced by non-vaccine serotypes 19A, 3, and 6A
I et al. · PubMed Central (PMC) · 1 Nov 2021