Peer-reviewed article
A Community Intervention to Increase Positive Parenting: A Three-Year Cohort Study in South Africa.
Ward CL, Lake MT, Kleyn LM, Mufamadi-Mathebula D, Parker W et al. ·
Summary
Written by AI, not yet AICS's view · claude-haiku-4-5-20251001This study evaluated a community-wide parenting intervention in South Africa designed to increase positive parenting and reduce corporal punishment over three years. About one in five parents attended a parenting programme. While corporal punishment showed a trend towards reduction and children's mental health improved by year three, positive parenting did not increase community-wide. Parent mental health, substance abuse, and intimate partner violence remained unchanged and undermined parenting quality and children's wellbeing.
Key points
- Only 20.5% of parents attended a parenting programme at least once despite community-wide availability
- Positive parenting did not increase across the whole community over the three-year period
- Parenting stress declined and children's mental health improved by year three, possibly through increased parent employment rather than the intervention
- Intimate partner violence, parent mental health, and parent alcohol misuse were unchanged and were associated with less positive parenting and more children's mental health symptoms
- The action media component appeared to be associated with small negative effects on positive parenting, parenting stress, and children's internalising and externalising behaviours
Limitations
The study cannot determine causality for improvements in children's mental health, as these may have resulted from increased parent employment rather than the intervention itself. Low programme uptake (20.5%) limits conclusions about the intervention's effectiveness when delivered at scale in community settings.
Abstract
Objective: We evaluated an intervention to increase positive parenting, reduce corporal punishment, and improve children's mental health community-wide. All Parenting for Lifelong Health programmes were available to all interested parents alongside an action media intervention designed to amplify positive parenting messages across the community. Method: Three community-wide surveys of parents and of children aged 10+ were conducted at baseline and at 18-month intervals. Parent and child surveys assessed parenting and corporal punishment; parent surveys also addressed intimate partner violence (IPV), parent and child mental health, parent alcohol misuse, and parenting stress. Results: 536 parent-child dyads were included in the surveys; 110 (20.5%) parents attended a parenting programme at least once. Positive parenting did not increase across the whole community; there was a trend towards reduction of corporal punishment. Parenting stress declined and children's mental health improved by the third survey, possibly through increased parent employment rather than the intervention. IPV, parent mental health, and parent alcohol misuse were unchanged, and were associated with less positive parenting and more children's mental health symptoms. The action media process may indeed have enabled diffusion of parenting information, but also appeared to be associated with small negative effects on positive parenting, parenting stress and children's internalising and externalising. Conclusions: Reduction in parenting stress, a trend towards a reduction in corporal punishment, and improvement in children's mental health, were observed by year three. Parents' mental health, substance abuse and IPV must be addressed alongside parenting interventions to improve both parenting and children's mental health.
Findings the Hub has extracted
Each claim below is labelled by its type of design and links back to this report.
- Intervention
- Community-wide Parenting for Lifelong Health programmes combined with an action media intervention to amplify positive parenting messages across the community
- Population
- Parents and children aged 10+ in South African communities; 536 parent-child dyads in surveys
Key finding
Positive parenting did not increase across the whole community