Evaluation report
Targeting men, women or both to reduce child marriage
Rachel Cassidy, Anaya Dam, Wendy Janssens, Umair Kiani, Karlijn Morsink ·
Summary
Written by AI, not yet AICS's view · claude-haiku-4-5-20251001This study tested an educational intervention in Pakistan designed to delay child marriage by targeting men, women, or both with the same programme. The research found that targeting men reduced child marriages in directly targeted households, while targeting women led to broader reductions across entire villages. The findings suggest that women are more hesitant to break from social norms individually, but when targeted, their influence spreads through gender-segregated social networks to reduce child marriage more widely.
Key points
- Targeting men alone or with women reduced child marriages only in directly targeted households
- Targeting women alone or with women and men reduced child marriages at the village level
- The intervention was an edutainment programme in a context where community norms favour early marriage
- Gender-segregated information transmission from targeted women to other households explains village-level effects
- Women are more hesitant to deviate from social norms without the support of spreading influence through networks
Limitations
The study was conducted only in Pakistan, so findings may not generalise to other contexts with different social norms or intervention delivery methods. The document does not provide detailed information about the specific content of the edutainment intervention or long-term follow-up beyond the initial measurements.
Abstract
We ask whether it is more effective to target men, women, or both - with the same intervention in the same context - to improve women's outcomes when behaviour is governed by gendered social norms. We conduct a cluster-randomized controlled trial of an edutainment intervention in Pakistan - aimed at delaying marriage of adolescent girls, whereas community norms favour early marriage. We find that targeting men, either alone or jointly with women, reduces child marriages in households directly targeted by the intervention. Targeting women, however, either alone or jointly with men, leads to sustained reductions in child marriages at the village level. To rationalize this pattern of results, we build on a model of Bayesian persuasion in the household, where women are more hesitant to deviate from social norms. We extend this by allowing for gender-segregated information transmission from targeted spouses to other households in the village.
Findings the Hub has extracted
Each claim below is labelled by its type of design and links back to this report.
- Intervention
- Edutainment intervention aimed at delaying marriage of adolescent girls
- Population
- Households and communities in Pakistan
Key finding
Targeting men alone or jointly with women reduced child marriages in directly targeted households