Peer-reviewed article
Medical Assessment and Management of Self-Inflicted Head Injury in an Inpatient Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) Setting
Patrick G, Smallwood J, Webb C ·
Summary
Written by AI, not yet AICS's view · claude-haiku-4-5-20251001This study examined whether medical staff in a UK child mental health hospital ward properly assessed and documented self-inflicted head injuries according to national clinical guidance. Researchers reviewed 52 incidents of head banging by young patients and found that only 56% received a doctor's review. When doctors did review cases, they documented fewer than half of the required assessment components, rarely provided safety advice, and seldom recorded their clinical concerns about transfer to emergency care.
Key points
- Only 56% of 52 head-banging incidents received a medical review; 32% had no doctor review
- Documentation of required history components met targets in only 2 of 9 areas; physical examination components met targets in 5 of 16 areas
- Safety netting advice was provided in only 16% of incidents, against national guidance recommendations
- Mean time to doctor review was 4.3 hours (range 1-16 hours)
- Documentation of ongoing doctor concerns requiring emergency transfer was recorded in only 6.6% of incidents
Limitations
This is an audit of one hospital ward over one month using incident logs and clinical notes, so findings may not represent practice elsewhere or over longer periods. The audit does not explain why documentation gaps occurred or assess the clinical impact of incomplete assessments on patient safety.
Abstract
Aims To ascertain whether current medical assessment and management of self-inflicted head injuries in an inpatient CAMHS setting conforms with current NICE guidance. Methods Incidents of self-inflicted head injury were identified on the incident logging system Ulysses. Incidents were matched to entries on Paris, the online clinical notes system. Data were collected from Paris on whether the incident was reviewed by a doctor, time until doctor review and which components of the NICE guidance were completed during the review. The data were collated into an Excel spreadsheet and analysed. Inclusion criteria were CAMHS inpatients at 1 Greater Manchester hospital during November 2021 who had an incident of ‘head banging’ recorded on Ulysses. Exclusion criteria were patients on ward A as the ward was found to have its own care plans for managing head banging rather than escalating to doctors. Results There were 52 incidents of head banging logged. 56% (n = 29) of incidents received a doctor review and 32% (n = 17) did not. For 10% (n = 5) of incidents a doctor review was declined and for 2% (n = 1) a review was conducted for another indication. The mean time taken until review was 4.3 hours with a range of 1 to 16 hours. NICE guidance lists 9 components of the history that should be covered. 1 component met the 100% target and 1 component was documented in > 50% of incidents. The remaining 7 components were documented in < 50% of incidents. NICE guidance lists 16 components of physical examination that should be completed. No components of the physical examination met the 100% target. 5 components were documented in > 50% of incidents. The remaining 11 components were documented in <50% of incidents. NICE guidance recommends verbal and written safety netting advice is given. Advice was given in 16% (n = 5) of incidents. NICE recommends a responsible adult remains with the patient for 24 hours, this was documented in 77% (n = 22) of incidents. NICE recommends ongoing doctor concerns necessitate patient transfer to A&E. Concerns/lack of concerns were documented in 6.6% (n = 2) of incidents. Conclusion This audit has demonstrated inconsistencies between doctor's documentation of self-inflicted head injuries in an inpatient CAMHS setting. The reviews do not meet the standards outlined by NICE. There is a good emphasis on gross neurology but less awareness of the need to document more subtle pathology and ongoing monitoring requirements.
Findings the Hub has extracted
Each claim below is labelled by its type of design and links back to this report.
- Intervention
- Implementation of NICE-guided medical assessment and documentation protocol for self-inflicted head injuries
- Population
- Children and adolescents admitted to inpatient CAMHS at one Greater Manchester hospital, November 2021
Key finding
56% of incidents received doctor review; 32% received no review