Peer-reviewed article
Children’s participation in Dutch youth care practice: an exploratory study into the opportunities for child participation in youth care from professionals’ perspective
Stephanie Elaine Rap, Verkroost Denise, Mariëlle R. Bruning ·
Summary
Written by AI, not yet AICS's view · claude-haiku-4-5-20251001This study examines how children participate in Dutch youth care decisions from the perspective of professionals. Since 2015, Dutch municipalities have been responsible for youth care, and child participation is supposed to be essential, but the study finds large differences between municipalities in how well they enable this. Children's participation is better regulated when court orders are involved in compulsory care, but most municipalities set the minimum age for participation at 12 years, leaving younger children with few opportunities to have a say.
Key points
- The Youth Act (2015) in the Netherlands assumes that mobilising and empowering families and enabling participation of children and parents is essential to implementing youth care services
- Substantial differences exist between municipalities in realising children's participation in decisions about their care and protection
- Municipalities have large discretion in shaping child participation in access to voluntary and coercive youth care
- Child participation is better regulated and implemented in compulsory youth care via court orders than in voluntary services
- The minimum age limit for child involvement in decision-making is typically 12 years, leaving younger children with scarce opportunities to participate
Limitations
This is an exploratory study examining professionals' perspectives on the legal opportunities and practical implementation of child participation, rather than directly assessing children's actual experiences or outcomes of participation. The study does not provide data on whether or how child participation affects the quality or effectiveness of youth care services.
Abstract
Since 2015, local municipalities in the Netherlands have been responsible for the organisation of the youth care and child protection system. One of the basic assumptions underlying the new Youth Act (2015) is the mobilisation and empowerment of the family to help solve their problems. Consequently, the participation of children and parents is essential in the implementation of youth care services. However, it seems that substantial differences exist between municipalities in realising children's participation in decisions that are taken concerning their care and protection. This article provides an interdisciplinary perspective on child participation; it explores both the legal opportunities for participation and the extent to which children can make use of these opportunities in practice. It is concluded that municipalities have large discretion in giving shape to child participation in the access to voluntary and coercive youth care. However, child participation is better regulated and implemented in practice with respect to compulsory youth care via court orders. Throughout almost the entire process, the minimum age limit from when children are involved in the decision-making process is 12 years, which means that children below that age have scarce opportunities to participate.